November Books
Dec. 1st, 2010 09:20 am37. Louisa May Alcott: The Woman Behind Little Women, Harriet Reisen. 302pp
This was a well-written biography and I enjoyed it. I've always admired Alcott's books (at least her children's ones - I am not interested in the pulp fiction she did), but didn't know a whole lot about her life, so I learned a lot.
There were a few statements I took issue with, and they may well be the result of poor proofreading, but for someone who appears to be as obsessed with Alcott as the author claims to be, I found it ridiculous that she made the three following erroneous remarks, all about events in the "Little Women" series.
Page 21: She says that the scene where Mr March and Demi are doing alphabet gymnastics is in "Little Men". It's not. It's in "Little Women" (or "Good Wives", to be perfectly accurate).
Page 139: I haven't pulled out my book to find the exact age of Beth at her death, but off the top of my head I know she wasn't 16. She was nearly 18 when Jo left for New York, so she was 19 or 20 when she died.
Page 238: She says that Jo had boy and girl twins, Daisy and Demi. She did not; Meg did. Jo had Rob and Teddy.
Aside from these errors, I really did enjoy the book, and found it really interesting to learn more about the Transcendental movement. It amazes me how many new and anti-Christian philosophies took root and grew like weeds in the 1840s: spiritism, Transcendentalism, evolution, et cetera. I was intrigued that she actually did mention the Millerite movement in passing, although she says they planted no crops in 1843, and as far as I am able to find in fact, some chose not to harvest crops. Anyway.
She had a hard life and strikes me as a very sad individual in whom the love of Christ would have made a world of difference. Working working working and never able to maintain happiness.
38. The Great Controversy, Ellen White. 678pp.
Third time through in three years. It gets better every time.
This was a well-written biography and I enjoyed it. I've always admired Alcott's books (at least her children's ones - I am not interested in the pulp fiction she did), but didn't know a whole lot about her life, so I learned a lot.
There were a few statements I took issue with, and they may well be the result of poor proofreading, but for someone who appears to be as obsessed with Alcott as the author claims to be, I found it ridiculous that she made the three following erroneous remarks, all about events in the "Little Women" series.
Page 21: She says that the scene where Mr March and Demi are doing alphabet gymnastics is in "Little Men". It's not. It's in "Little Women" (or "Good Wives", to be perfectly accurate).
Page 139: I haven't pulled out my book to find the exact age of Beth at her death, but off the top of my head I know she wasn't 16. She was nearly 18 when Jo left for New York, so she was 19 or 20 when she died.
Page 238: She says that Jo had boy and girl twins, Daisy and Demi. She did not; Meg did. Jo had Rob and Teddy.
Aside from these errors, I really did enjoy the book, and found it really interesting to learn more about the Transcendental movement. It amazes me how many new and anti-Christian philosophies took root and grew like weeds in the 1840s: spiritism, Transcendentalism, evolution, et cetera. I was intrigued that she actually did mention the Millerite movement in passing, although she says they planted no crops in 1843, and as far as I am able to find in fact, some chose not to harvest crops. Anyway.
She had a hard life and strikes me as a very sad individual in whom the love of Christ would have made a world of difference. Working working working and never able to maintain happiness.
38. The Great Controversy, Ellen White. 678pp.
Third time through in three years. It gets better every time.